 Join our Discord!
|
| If you have been locked out of your account you can request a password reset here. |
Difference between revisions of "Talk:Black Hawk Down"
(→Weapon used by delta force: Query about picking up enemy magazines.) |
|||
| Line 8: | Line 8: | ||
Isn't it more likely that Randy Shughart was actually carrying a Springfield M21 rather than the M14? | Isn't it more likely that Randy Shughart was actually carrying a Springfield M21 rather than the M14? | ||
| − | :No, he was carrying a M14 during the actual battle and it is in his Medal of Honor | + | :No, he was carrying a M14 during the actual battle and it is in his Medal of Honor citation. So its definitely a M14. |
| + | |||
| + | == Mistake? == | ||
| + | There's a scene in the movie (1:37:53) where Yurek, Nelson and Twombly are about to rejoin the other Rangers at the Black Hawk crash site. While Yurek is on the radio to Eversmann (Josh Hartnett's character) he grabs a mag out of a Type 47 that a dead Somali soldier is still holding. Since the Rangers are all carrying 5.56 NATO M4A2s and FN Minimis, what would be the point of grabbing a 7.62mm mag? Seems like an odd oversight considering the camera kinda focuses on him taking the mag, and they've worked quite hard to maintain accuracy and detail in the film. Any ideas? Am I missing something? [[User:DamageW|DamageW]] 06:17, 10 May 2009 (UTC) | ||
Revision as of 06:17, 10 May 2009
Weapon used by delta force
M4 was issued in 1994 before the battle which took place in 1993 ...the weapon seen in the movie and used by Delta operators was CAR-15
- If you'll look at the upper reciever and carry handle/rear-sight assembly, you'll see they match the M16A2-style of the early-model M4 carbine as shown in the picture above the screenshots. The CAR-15 (also known as the Colt Commando) used the recievers and carry handle/rear sight assembly of the M16A1. Orca1 9904 22:18, 18 August 2007 (UTC)
Also, the stock is wrong for the CAR15...its an M4
Isn't it more likely that Randy Shughart was actually carrying a Springfield M21 rather than the M14?
- No, he was carrying a M14 during the actual battle and it is in his Medal of Honor citation. So its definitely a M14.
Mistake?
There's a scene in the movie (1:37:53) where Yurek, Nelson and Twombly are about to rejoin the other Rangers at the Black Hawk crash site. While Yurek is on the radio to Eversmann (Josh Hartnett's character) he grabs a mag out of a Type 47 that a dead Somali soldier is still holding. Since the Rangers are all carrying 5.56 NATO M4A2s and FN Minimis, what would be the point of grabbing a 7.62mm mag? Seems like an odd oversight considering the camera kinda focuses on him taking the mag, and they've worked quite hard to maintain accuracy and detail in the film. Any ideas? Am I missing something? DamageW 06:17, 10 May 2009 (UTC)